Vaccine mandates are essential to future health of U.S.
Alina Health recently mandated vaccines for their employees. They claim this was to keep their staff/patients healthy.
CORRECTION: In our print edition the photo caption inaccurately stated that vaccine was administered at school. This information is incorrect. The student did not receive her vaccine at school.
“We have to do the right thing, help each other out, get the vaccine, and move forward,” principle engineer Aaron Stein said. Faith in the COVID-19 vaccine has been a controversial topic for the last year. For society to go back to “normal,” it is essential that 70-90% of population of the U.S. gets vaccinated. Realistically, the one way for this to happen is through a vaccine mandate.
“We have vaccine mandates on everything from smallpox to polio,” band director Dennis Lindsay explained.
The polio vaccine was first introduced in 1953, and now it is a mandated vaccine. It has been around this long, and it is still going strong.
“Thanks to the polio vaccine, dedicated health care professionals and parents who vaccinate their children on schedule, polio has been eliminated in this country for more than thirty years. This means that there is no year-round transmission of poliovirus in the United States,” the CDC explained in a case study.
According to the article, 15,000 cases of paralysis were discovered each year prior to polio vaccines being developed. People committing to getting the polio vaccine eventually brought the cases down to 10 by the 1970’s. Having this vaccine mandated almost completely eliminated the virus. Science today is much more advanced then when the polio vaccine was created. There is over 50 more years of virus/vaccine experience for a better vaccine to be developed. It is safe and logical to mandate the COVID-19 vaccine based on these patterns from history.
Certain businesses and facilities such as Alina Health are taking the bold step towards ensuring safety for their staff and patients. They believe that taking this step and mandating vaccines will ensure the safety for their staff and all of the patients they see.
“As of Friday Oct. 1 all employees, volunteers, students and contracted staff with Alina Health are required to have at least one dose of COVID-19 vaccine… Ensuring that our employees are vaccinated not only sends an important signal to the community that we embrace safety, but that we continue to take every possible step to bring about the end of the COVID-19 pandemic,” Dianne Sandberg wrote in an article from KARE 11.
The fact that most people who die from COVID-19 are the unvaccinated population is a testament to the fact that COVID-19 vaccines work. It is important to address breakthrough infections know to not even the vaccine is perfect. Nonetheless, having a vaccine mandate in place increases the amount of people with immunity and lowers the rates of hospitalization/death.
“We know from hospital data the vast majority of people getting very sick or dying are unvaccinated. Yes, there are breakthrough infections, but those people rarely get very sick or die,” Stein said.
Overall, it is constitutional to mandate vaccines to make sure the general population is healthy. The Department of Justice has also said it is lawful for businesses to mandate vaccines.
“States have long had the constitutional authority to mandate vaccinations, which the Supreme Court has upheld twice, first in 1905 and then in 1922,” Lawrence O. Gostin wrote in an article from Scientific American.Â
Lindsay explained that a colleague he has is un-vaccinated, and got COVID-19. He was in critical care for over two weeks. He explained that he is expected to be on oxygen for the rest of his life because of lung damage.
“The vaccine was the only thing that would’ve taken a jab. It would’ve greatly reduced his risk of having any kind of major health effects,” Lindsay explained.
Lindsay’s friend was a marathon runner. After having COVID-19, and facing long term effects, he is never expected to race again. A vaccine mandate could have prevented him from losing something he loved.
In December 2020, the COVID-19 vaccine appeared. Over the last 10 months; so much time, research, and trials have been put into it. Now, more than ever, it has proved that it is safe, and it works. A mandate for this vaccine will keep people safe, and pull us out of the “new normal” COVID-19 has created.
My name is Allie Schlagel, I'm a Layout Editor for the pony express. I'm a junior at Stillwater area Highschool. I play basketball, and French horn, and...
Cecilia Conery • Dec 20, 2021 at 5:56 pm
I really like how the lead was a quote that engaged people into the story. The quotes, as well as different forms of evidence completes this opinion story, and expresses an opinion well. I like the comparison to the polio vaccine as well.
Brooke Elfert • Dec 20, 2021 at 12:43 pm
The variety of quote sources you used really kept this story balanced and more interesting than if you were to solely focus on one opinion and focus of the story. You did a great job taking a strong stance within a variety of supports. Super well written and great flow!
Mikai Tasch • Dec 14, 2021 at 12:02 pm
I loved your story because you had plenty of information to back your opinion. You did a nice job citing where you got your information from. Overall, I thought your story was very interesting and informative.
Jasmine Allison • Dec 8, 2021 at 12:09 pm
I really liked how you used a historical piece of evidence to support your argument. I also liked how you brought in lots of facts and weaved them into your article. I also like how you brought in people’s views and opinions. If I were to suggest something: maybe use subheadings to organize the article. Great job overall though!
Nissa Wilcox • Dec 7, 2021 at 3:27 pm
Great job Allie, you included helpful quotes and solid facts on why the vaccine should be mandated. You got a lot of evidence from a variety of sources to make a strong argument and conclude with a call for normalcy.
Ava Stein • Dec 4, 2021 at 11:33 am
I like how this story has different perspectives on why vaccine mandates are essential. The story is very fact-based with evidence supporting it and I learned a lot from it. It also gets personal to show how much COVID-19 can affect one person’s life.