The student news site of Stillwater Area High School

U.S. economy seeing large benefits, result of immigrants

April 3, 2017

The U.S. is a  large leading nation in the world, known to be a land of promise for those from other countries. Immigrants from all over the world have taken advantage of the U.S. being a free nation with opportunity, and  to search for the elusive American dream. The U.S. economy  and workforce has seen large benefits as a result of  immigration, undocumented and documented.

Immigrants have become a vital part to this country over the last hundred years, and with executive orders like the Travel Ban and the building of the wall on Mexico’s border, causes many immigrants to fear their safety and security. As a nation, the U.S. must allow immigrants with no criminal records to live and work here, as their presence is so vital to this country both economically and culturally.

According the Diana Furchtgott-Roth of the Manhattan Institute, immigrants reduce labor shortages in both low and high skilled job markets, by filling in available jobs. Immigrant workers take the jobs that many Americans take for granted or they think are beneath them, like a minimum wage job at fast food chain or being a janitor. These are common stereotypes of immigrants, specifically colored immigrants. Although these jobs are taken by many, immigrants can also hold jobs that pay comfortably and have higher ranking status. Their far reach in the job spectrum is just one of the reasons we rely on them.

Immigration stimulates our economy. With a larger population, economic stimulus is much easier to accomplish, and immigrants are the only thing keeping our population on an upward trend.”

— Leo Montie

Junior Leo Montie explained, “Immigration stimulates our economy. With a larger population, economic stimulus is much easier to accomplish, and immigrants are the only thing keeping our population on an upward trend.”

Our economic state is a huge advantage of having immigration, but the U.S. has a moral obligation to protect, whether they are immigrants looking to start a new life or refugees seeking political asylum. In 2015, there were 140,093 refugees living in the U.S. according to the Office of Refugee resettlement. A bulk of these people came from Burma, Cuba, and Iraq, many of these people have seen treacherous hardships in their countries.

Senior Madison Fry said, “The path to citizenship is a long one and I think every human deserves the chance of creating a livelihood for themselves and their family.”

Many U.S. politicians are very strong in their beliefs that immigration is detrimental, specifically current president Donald Trump. Trump has made harsh comments about immigration and refugees, such as calling Mexican immigrants “rapists and drug dealers” at one his rallies during his campaign. Statements like this and his executive orders like the Travel Ban and the Wall by the Mexico border, have given him enormous support from Americans. This rhetoric creates division between immigrants and citizens, which need not be there always.

The path to citizenship is a long one and I think every human deserves the chance of creating a livelihood for themselves and their family.”

— Madison Fry

In 2015, there was 5,818 cases of hate crimes involving multiple victims. Approximately 59.2 percent of these were racially or ethnically bias. There must be a better unity between citizens and immigrants, which can start by blocking out the divisive rhetoric of world leaders like President Trump and creating a peaceful coexistence with immigrants Americans.

While propaganda from world leaders plays a large part in hate crimes and negative views towards immigration, harmful stereotypes in pop culture can further hate crimes and create more unnecessary divisions.  For example, many African and Mexican Americans are portrayed as gang members, drug dealers, and thieves in movies, television and literature. This impacts the ability for them to get jobs and loans along with the possibilities of being victims of hate crimes.

A chief argument from conservative Americans is that why  undocumented immigrants don’t apply for legal citizenship. The naturalization process taken at least seven years to become a citizen and sometimes can take up to 20 years for residency.

“Without it needing to be stated, immigrating legally to the U.S has its share of difficulties, and the largest issue of the process is likely the timetable. It can take so long that many people will weigh the benefits of waiting and decide that attempting to cross the border without documentation may be the correct process. If the process were made more simple, it is likely that we would see undocumented immigration dip,” Montie said.

With all the benefits and moral obligations to uphold, undocumented and  primarily law abiding immigrants still face harsh treatment in America, and face the the constant possibility of  poverty, separation from family, and possible death if deported. The U.S. can do  much more to protect the rights of immigrants, but with current law makers the possibilities seem bleak than ever.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


4 Responses to “U.S. economy seeing large benefits, result of immigrants”

  1. Jack Nolte on April 5th, 2017 7:20 pm

    This editorial uses misleading statistics. The editorial only displays the number of incoming refugees in place of the number of annual immigrants. The number of legal immigrants per year is closer to 1 million legal immigrants, and much higher if counting undocumented immigrants.


  2. Cates Eliasen on April 30th, 2017 8:52 pm

    Interesting viewpoint. The positives of immigration are often ignored in favor of focusing on the negatives, which leads to a lack of knowledge for many on immigration. I enjoyed how stood against the argument that immigrants should just become legal citizens, because as you stated in the article, that can be very difficult and sometimes impossible for many people who would make outstanding U.S. citizens. Leo’s quotes were well used and your information was well researched with lots of statistics, which in this sort of situation can speak louder than words. Interesting article; probably my favorite that you have written!


  3. Jared Taylor on May 5th, 2017 12:44 pm

    This was an interesting take on this topic. While the story is well written with an okay inforgraphic , some of the facts and numbers just don’t seem right. When you click on the website link the website shows only a few countries with refugees not all of them and the list is alphabetical so some countries that have a high refugee count may not be shown.


  4. Grace McDonough on May 7th, 2017 9:15 pm

    I thought that the student quotes used in this article were incredibly strong and informed. While the article shifted in focus to hate crimes, the author did a good job of connecting this topic to the economics of refugees. I wish there would have been more stats about immigrants in the economy, but I found the information included informing. The author properly recognized the opposition and thoroughly addressed it. Overall, this article was articulate and well done.


The Pony Express intends for this area to be used to foster healthy thought-provoking discussion. Comments are expected to adhere to the standards of the Pony Express and to be respectful and constructive. Furthermore, we do not permit any of the following inappropriate content including: Libel or defamatory statements, any copyrighted, trademarked, or intellectual property of others, the use of profanity and foul language or personal attacks. All comments are reviewed and approved by staff to ensure that they meet the standards of this publication. The Pony Express does not allow anonymous comments. We require a name and valid email address submitted. This email address will not be displayed but will be used to confirm your comments. Online comments that are found in violation of these policies will be removed as quickly as possible.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.

The Pony Express • Copyright 2017 • FLEX WordPress Theme by SNOLog in